CROSSVILLE CHRONICLE

Opinion

 

S.E. Wood
"A Conservative Viewpoint"

We'll never know who
won the China standoff

This is either the third or fourth article I have written with this same title. The first such article concerned the Chinese investment in our 1996 presidential election. Next was the effort of the Chinese Liberation Army to lease the San Diego Naval Base. Then the theft and/or purchase of our defense secrets. Or maybe it was the Chinese control of the Panama Canal. I forget. It seems every month or so there has been another U.S./China crisis, and it doesn't look like it's going to get any better.

Unless you have been living in a cave for the past several weeks, you know by now that this time the crisis was the inadvertent collision of a Chinese jet fighter and a U.S. reconnaissance plane over the South China Sea. They say we did it. We say they did it. Who knows? However, one would think it rather difficult for the military adaptation of the old Lockheed Electra to run into anything. Those of you over the age of 40 will recall that Eastern Airlines bought a whole bunch of these old relics back in the '50s. No sooner were they put into service, that their lack of speed and maneuverability made them obsolete, and their cost no doubt contributed to the eventual demise of Eastern. So it does stretch credibility to believe that a 40-year-old Electra could abruptly turn into the path of anything ... much less a supersonic jet fighter.

But still, the Chinese wanted an official American apology for our involvement in the collision, and for landing on the first spot of dry land our pilot could find. And we wanted our plane and crew returned ASAP. Sen. Barbara Feinstein, D-CA, was eager to apologize, and did so on behalf of the U.S. Congress. Jesse Jackson, D-Chicago, did so on behalf of everybody else.

But in the end, we all got a little bit of something. President Bush wrote, in English, that he was "very sorry" for the mishap. The Chinese promptly interpreted that into their language as an "apology." They got their version of an American apology. We got our crew back, but not our plane ... which by now has been emptied of anything of value.

But the Chinese Commies did cave. Why? If we can believe our news commentators, the Commies held all the cards. There was no need for them to hurry a settlement, with Jesse Jackson having already applied for a visa to come rescue our servicemen and women, and Bill Clinton already scheduled to visit China next month to pick up anybody Jesse might have missed. All the Commies had to do was sit tight and wait for Jackson and Clinton to deliver both a major diplomatic failure and major political embarrassment to President Bush and the United States of America.

So, what happened? You and I will never know, because we will never know all the facts. And that is probably the way it should be. President Bush says he won. Chairman Jiang Zemin says he won. Even Jesse claims he played an important role. But if I had to bet, I would say that it was not the diplomatic expertise of the current administration, or the Communist fear of military retaliation, or even the spiritual advice of the Rev. Jesse Jackson that caused the change of heart. But rather, it was an explanation of the current-day Chinese facts of life, as explained by representatives of Nike, Kmart, Wal-Mart, Dollar General, and of course, Big Lots!

And whether we like it or not, it's an American fact of life, too!

Use your browser's back button to return to the previous page