CROSSVILLE CHRONICLE

Opinion

 

David Spates
"Therefore I Am"

I want my change back
from the federal government

OK, here's the scenario. You're busy in your office when one of your co-workers asks you if you'd like to go for lunch. Unfortunately, you've got many papers to shuffle that day, and killing an hour for lunch just isn't feasible, but, you ask, if he could bring back something for you, that would be great.

So you order a triple bacon cheeseburger, a side of chicken remnants pounded into nugget form, an extra large order of seasoned fries and a large chocolate shake. After calling your doctor to cancel your annual physical, you slip your co-worker an Alexander Hamilton and go back to work.

An hour or so later, Johnny Co-Worker returns with your feast. You thank him profusely and wait for him to hand you the change.

He doesn't.

After a quick mental calculation, you determine that you should have received about $3 in change. After all, Winky's Grease Pit charges about $3.50 for the burger, $1.50 for fried chicken residue, $1 for the fries and $1.50 for the "homemade" shake that you swear tastes like it contains sawdust. The grand total should have been about $6.50 plus tax.

Although you've got your No. 3 myocardial-infarction-in-a-bag meal, you're still short the change from the $10 bill. Johnny Co-Worker is pocketing your hard-earned three bucks, and with expenses like the wife's breast enhancement, your 7-year-old son's Playstation 2 and your 3-year-old daughter's beauty pageant tiara in your household budget, you don't have coin to spare.

Well, guess what? Johnny Co-Worker and your federal government are doing the same thing, except when Johnny palms your $3 he doesn't call it a "budget surplus."

I don't pretend to understand the intricacies of federal government finances, but I do when I feel like I'm getting the 1040 shoved down my throat all the while receiving a pat on the head.

The U.S. budget surplus soared to a record $237 billion in fiscal year 2000, which ended Sept. 30. Al Gore and George W. Bush have big plans for the extra dinero, but I won't bore you with the details. They still have a week's worth of campaigning to do that themselves.

What gripes me is the notion that the extra money is the government's to spend! It's not! It's my money, it's your money, and it's Johnny Co-Worker's money! It's the taxpayers' money! The government took too much money from us, and it's not going to give it back.

Let me say that again for emphasis.

The government took too much money from us, and it's not going to give it back.

How did we Americans get hoodwinked into believing that the federal government (or state governments or even local governments, for that matter) has its own money to spend? It's not the governments' money, it's our money. We taxpayers provide the money governmental bodies spend, and if those governmental bodies come to the realization that they have taken too much of our money, then they should return the difference.

It's that simple.

This notion of the government as being a kindly old father who doles out gifts to his children has gotten way out of hand. In an issue of the Crossville Chronicle last week, we ran a story about the mock election at Cumberland County High School. Bush beat Gore like a bongo. CCHS junior Holli Lloyd was asked why she thought Bush won so convincingly. She was quoted as saying a major reason is that Bush "gives us money and what we need for education."

I hate to single out one individual, especially a person so young as Holli, but her comment clearly states what I fear so many people actually believe. The government (or president) "gives us money." The government has no money to give. The government is supposed to decide how to best allocate the money we pay in taxes. The idea that the government has its own money and we must drop to one knee and say "pretty please with sugar on top" before we receive any benefit is atrocious.

In the business world a "budget surplus" is called a "profit," and as far as I know, the government is supposed to be a non-profit organization. Just a little something to keep in mind when you head to the polls next week or when you order your next triple bacon cheeseburger.

Use your browser's back button to return to the previous page