CROSSVILLE CHRONICLE

Opinion

 

Mike Moser
"I Say"

Is the state approaching
tax reform the right way?

They tell us we need an income tax. They tell us we need tax reform. So they cut our services and close our revenue-making venues in an effort to strong-arm us into accepting a form of taxation that even the General Assembly leadership cannot agree on.

Yet some of the same politicians fly their spouses around the country in the state-owned plane, charging their trips to the taxpayers of Tennessee. I just don't get it. And God knows what we don't about how our money is spent in Nashville.

For those of you who have heard me moan about the want of true statesmen in this country, I apologize ahead of time for subjecting you to yet another unsolicited railing about the lack of men and women with foresight and vision in positions of influence and authority.

I am now convinced more than ever that this malady of elected government is not restricted to the federal level, but is alive and well in Nashville as well as in some areas of local government.

How many of you out there really believe that the so-called budget crisis is as bad as the Sundquist administration would have us believe? I am having a hard time swallowing this. I admit tax reform might be good for Tennessee.

But isn't this the same state that labels road funds as untouchable but ranks low in education spending when compared to other states, even our neighbors in the Southeast U.S.? Is it unreasonable for me to believe that investing in the education and training of our kids today translates into a more educated and competitive work force drawing higher wages and spending more money in the Tennessee economy? Or is that a simple way to look at it?

They tell us we are broke, yet House Speaker Jimmy Naifeh uses the state airplane at a cost of about $5,000 to fly himself, two aides, and their wives to a conference in Charleston, SC.

The state tells us they will be cutting classroom positions next year, but travel for legislators' spouses is not cut? The meeting Naifeh, his wife (a Capitol Hill lobbyist), his assistant and her husband (the state treasurer) and Naifeh's chief of staff and his wife attended was the national organization of legislative presiding officers.

While the meeting might have been important for Naifeh, how did the state benefit by the other five fliers attending? And if their attendance was required, would it have not been cheaper to travel on round-trip airfares on commercial flights?

Naifeh justified using the state plane because he had to be back in Tennessee the same day so he could host his benefit golf tournament. Now that might be popular in the Golf Capitol of Tennessee, but it befuddles my thinking, to a degree.

When The Tennessean checked the convention schedule against flight logs, they found out the executive committee on which Naifeh serves had already concluded its meeting. But I am getting hung up on details.

Then there is the governor's famous decision to close eight state parks. So much for "Follow me to Tennessee," huh?

That one hit home. Sundquist's decision to close the parks has cost the state $715,000 in reimbursement funds from the National Park Service for land acquisition for the Cumberland Trail, which passes through Cumberland County.

And, while the parks are closed, the state will not be eligible to receive money from the Land and Water Conservation Fund.

If the purpose of this closing was to save the $3 million the administration said would be saved, well, my math says the loss of three-quarters of a million in federal funds brings the total down to $2.3. Then figure in revenue generated by dollar rollover from tourists, local and out-of-state, who visit these parks, that is now lost.

What have we gained?

Burgess Falls boasts about 400,000 visitors a year. If each of them spent an average of $5 while on their outing that they normally would not have spent, well, you do the math.

This week one of the most beautiful parks in the state, Frozen Head State Park in nearby Morgan County, was closed to the public. Not only are we losing tourist-generated dollars to our already staggering economy, we are putting loyal state employees on the unemployment rolls.

It is estimated Frozen Head generates over $5 million per year in tourist revenue for the state and local economy. That is money Morgan County and Tennessee can ill-afford to lose.

I heard the other day that employees of the Department of Children Services in Cumberland County have been relocated to Putnam County. With the workload these public servants face on a daily basis, I can see that being beneficial to the welfare of our community.

Are we being strong-armed into accepting a state income tax? I don't know, but it sure seems like that is what is happening. I am not necessarily against a state income tax, but I will never accept it without someone in Nashville explaining it to me in everyday terms that I can understand, sans the emotional and economic blackmail.

· · ·
Mike Moser is the editor of the Crossville Chronicle. His column is published periodically on Fridays.

Use your browser's back button to return to the previous page