CROSSVILLE CHRONICLE

Opinion

 

Dorothy Copus Brush
"Random Thoughts"

(Low Tax) not the only
interesting case -- Part II

By Dorothy Copus Brush
Chronicle staffwriter

Last week's column began the story of an early Crossville murder. H.H. drowned his young wife in 1897 and was sentenced to hang. There were appeals to higher courts all through 1898, and in January 1899 the State Supreme Court sustained the lower courts' verdict, and the hanging was set for March 13, 1899. However, Gov. Benton McMillin gave H.H. a 30-day respite, and the date was changed to April 13.

Cumberland County had existed for only 44 years, and this was the first hanging they had ever been required to carry out. A statute gave Sheriff Garrison specific instructions on how to proceed.

The gallows were to be erected not farther than two miles from the jail, and it must be put in an enclosure. Between 30 and 50 people will be allowed admittance to witness the execution. The rope used for the hanging is to be a one-inch manila hemp; pliable, yet firm in texture. The rope must be placed in position on the night before the execution and is to be greased and must have suspended on it twice the weight of the criminal. This is done to take out the slack.

H.H. was returned to Crossville from Nashville the third week in March, and a <I>Chronicle<I> reporter visited him in his cell. He wrote, "Considering the position he is in, he seems wonderfully resigned to his fate. He was but to glance."

The night before the execution the paper stated that 50 to 100 visitors arrived in town "awaiting expectantly the coming of the morrow, when it was known H.H. would surely hang." The time of the execution was not published. Sheriff Garrison had yielded to the wishes of the prisoner and his father that it be early morning. On April 13, 1899, the trap fell at 6:53 a.m., and H.H. was pronounced dead at 7:04.

By mid-morning a crowd of not less than 1,200 or 1,500 people were in town, and the paper stated, "Many were much disappointed when they learned the thing was over. The remains in a casket were exposed to view in the jail yard and not less than 100 people viewed the corpse."

Shortly after H.H. had been imprisoned in 1897, he gave the details of the murder, but on the night before his execution, he wrote the full and true confession of all that had led to his crime.

After his marriage, he and his wife lived with his family. His mother was not pleased with his young wife, and she urged him to kill her. At last "driven almost crazy by her persuasions," H.H. made two attempts at murder before he finally succeeded. He told his mother that all was ended now, and that he was in a "pretty fix." She told him to keep quiet, and it would never be found out. "But within 48 hours I was being guarded by the sheriff to prevent a mob from wreaking vengeance on me."

Then, H.H. added another dimension to his confession. Again, because of his mother's nagging, he tried twice to kill his father. The confession ended with these words, "In view of all the horrible crimes which my mother has caused me to attempt, and knowing she is the cause of me doing all these things, I still love her and hope to meet her in Heaven."

This sad chapter in Crossville history came to mind when, as the Looper trial ended, it was described as the most shocking in local history. It is for you to decide.

Use your browser's back button to return to the previous page