CROSSVILLE CHRONICLE

Opinion

 

Dorothy Copus Brush
"Random Thoughts"

A look at the Coal Creek War, Part II

Today we know it as Lake City, but in 1891 it was the small town of Coal Creek, populated by unemployed coal miners. They had been locked out of the mines because they had asked to be paid in cash rather than company scrip. Now, they were struggling to feed and house their families.

The companies continued mining operations with prison labor. The state began the practice in 1866 and called it the prison lessee contract, which allowed companies to use prisoners at any lawful occupation they had worked in before. The Knoxville Iron Company Mine had used the prison release since 1877 and had more than 130 convicts. The practice had been tolerated, but the miners silently disapproved.

When prison labor was brought to the Briceville, TN, Mining Company, just south of Coal Creek, in July 1891, tempers flared. With so many miners locked out of work, bringing in more prisoners to replace them was just too much. On July15, 300 miners, armed with old guns, marched in the dark of night to the stockade holding the prisoners at Briceville. They surprised the few guards and demanded the prisoners be released to them so they could be sent to Knoxville by train.

At a signal from the leaders, torches blazed, and the size of the group was too large to try to stop. Their demands were met, and prisoners and guards were marched to Coal Creek and put aboard the train to Knoxville. The Anderson County sheriff declined to intervene and turned it over to the Knox County sheriff.

In Nashville, Gov. Buchanan received telegrams asking for two or more military companies at once because local law enforcement was unable to handle the situation. Shortly, the governor, his labor commissioner and Col. Sevier were on a train headed for Knoxville. The train stopped in Chattanooga to pick up two companies of Tennessee militiamen, young, part-time soldiers who had used guns only for target practice. Arriving in Knoxville, the train added the boxcar filled with the prisoner laborers and another small group of militiamen before proceeding to Coal Creek.

Col. Granville Sevier, a direct descendent of John Sevier, was in charge of the troops brought to guard the mines. From Thursday, when they arrived, to Monday all was quiet, but in the dark of Sunday night more than 1,000 miners from as far away as Harlan County, KY, were headed for Coal Creek on foot and horseback. Before sunrise Monday, they had surrounded the mine stockade and, when Sevier realized their strength, he surrendered and again the convicts and the militia made the march to the boxcars at Briceville.
That accomplished, the miners converged on the Knoxville Iron Company stockade just a mile from Coal Creek. The prisoners there were freed and put aboard a second train. Not a shot had been fired, but the valley was free of all convict slave labor and militia.

In the next few days, a 60 day cooling off period was agreed to. This allowed the governor to call the state legislature into a special session to wrestle with the subject of prison lessees. During this period, the state prison authority visited the Coal Creek-Briceville mines and found the deplorable conditions the convicts had to endure.

A state senator described the situation as a rebellion and urged that a military force be used to suppress it. Another legislator foolishly questioned the citizenship of the miners. In truth, 75 percent were Tennessee natives and descendents of Sevier, David Crockett and Isaac Shelby.

Little was accomplished in Nashville and, as the 60 days neared the end, the miner's committee recognized a violent element was taking control among the miners. They held a final meeting where they, as a committee, resigned. The miners were turned loose to be guided by their own consciences.

Use your browser's back button to return to the previous page